Questioning Difficult Episodes in The Ramayana and Mahabharata – A Modern Perspective

Part 1: Power, Duty, and Moral Dilemmas

Can we respect and adore certain characters in The Ramayana and Mahabharata, but simultaneously question their actions and behaviors as well as disagree with them?

The Ramayana, Mahabharata, and Puranic traditions have guided generations in thinking about dharma, duty, sacrifice, and justice. Yet some of their stories and incidents remain a mystery and deeply uncomfortable, particularly when considered through the lens of modern life.

Note: the purpose of this article is not to diminish revered figures, question divinity, or dismiss the circumstances and traditional interpretations surrounding these stories. It is to ask difficult questions respectfully: what happened, who bore the consequences, how would these events be viewed today under the microscope and what can these events teach us today? Also, these are certain stories and events that I have chosen to highlight, but they are not all inclusive and there might be stories that you believe should be included here such as Abhimanyu’s killing in the Chakravyuha.

Some episodes depict clear wrongdoing; others involve competing duties, divine purposes that we don’t comprehend, or details that vary across retellings. They should not all be judged alike. But all can invite thoughtful reflection, and it is ok for us to disagree with them and not like the outcomes or the events themselves.

1. Ravana and Sita – Power and Desire Trump Consent

Ravana’s abduction and captivity of Sita is condemned within the Ramayana. His learning, strength, and devotion did not give him the right to kidnap her against her wishes and objections.

Modern parallel: Think of a powerful CEO who repeatedly pursues a female employee despite her refusals, believing his wealth, status, success or influence entitles him to her attention. Or an influential man who uses threats, financial dependence, or social pressure to prevent a woman from leaving a relationship. We see versions of this in workplace harassment, coercive relationships, and situations where powerful individuals believe the rules don’t apply to them.



2. Parashurama and Renuka – Obedience vs Conscience

In mythology, Jamadagni ordered his sons to kill their mother, Renuka when she happened to observe a king or Gandharva and had a moment of distraction. Parashurama obeyed and later used a boon to restore her life. Traditional readings emphasize exceptional spiritual circumstances and obedience, but the event still unsettles modern readers. Cut off your mother’s head? My interpretation: she happened to see a prominent and good-looking individual, got captivated for a second and lost in thought…and then she was completely condemned by her husband for that moment’s lapse.

Modern parallel: Imagine a dad demands that his son disowns his mom because she supposedly dishonored the family, or in the corporate world, a senior executive instructing an employee to falsify financial statements to protect the company. The individual faces a choice between obeying someone they respect and doing what they know is clearly wrong. We often teach children to respect their parents and employees to follow their superiors, but what happens when that authority is abused? Should loyalty ever require us to abandon our conscience and what we feel to be right and wrong?

3. Dronacharya and Ekalavya - Talent, Access, Privilege and Sabotage

Ekalavya developed extraordinary archery skills independently while honoring Drona as his teacher. Drona later demanded his right thumb as guru dakshina, compromising his abilities so he would not be able to rival his dear Arjuna.

Modern parallel: See my previous article where I talk about this and discuss modern day examples of Arjuna, Karna and Eklavya.

Imagine a talented student from a disadvantaged background who teaches himself programming and outperforms graduates from prestigious universities, only to be denied opportunities because he lacks the right credentials on his resume or connections. Or a manager who deliberately withholds a promotion from a high-performing employee because that person threatens the career prospects of a favored protégé. This isn’t simply discrimination; it’s actively suppressing talent to preserve someone else’s advantage. How often do we reward privilege over merit and then convince ourselves the system is fair?


4. Yudhishthira and Draupadi – The Limits of Righteousness

This is why I don’t like Yudhishthira as a character. During the dice game, Yudhishthira wagered his possessions, his brothers, himself, and then Draupadi. She was dragged by Dushasana by her hair, half clothed into the royal court and no one did anything. Draupadi challenged the validity and legality of the wager: having lost himself, did he still have the right to stake her? The epic itself raises the objection.

Modern parallel: Imagine a husband who secretly uses his wife’s savings or jointly owned property to settle gambling debts without checking with her. Or a respected business leader who makes a reckless decision that puts employees’ livelihoods at risk yet expects forgiveness because of his otherwise impeccable reputation. The consequences fall on people who never agreed to take those risks. Yudhishthira’s reputation for righteousness makes his actions even more troubling to me. Shouldn’t those regarded as virtuous be held to a higher standard, rather than excused because of their reputation?

5. Rama and Vali - Justice and the Means Used

This event in the Ramayana I find quite perplexing and troubling knowing the character and image of Rama. Rama killed Vali while being hidden during Vali’s battle with Sugriva. Vali questioned Rama and said who are you, you don’t even know me, why are you interfering, how could you kill me via ambush as a kshatriya who has a code?

This is one of those events in the Ramayana where I don’t think Rama really has a legitimate answer. Rama defended his actions and explained to Vali that what he did was to punish Vali’s wrong doings and misbehavior towards Sugriva, and he was fulfilling his duty as a king and warrior. This makes me cringe! Can an outsider come in, interlope and insert themselves into a situation and do such a thing? I totally acknowledge that Vali was completely wrong in expelling Sugriva and taking his wife, Ruma, but the result seems to outweigh the misdeeds and the manner that Vali met his demise.

Modern parallel: Imagine a government seeking to remove a corrupt leader but doing so through an extra-judicial killing or hit rather than a transparent legal process. Or a company discovering that an executive has committed misconduct and secretly destroying his career through fabricated allegations rather than conducting a fair investigation. The underlying objective may be justified, but the method raises a separate ethical and moral question. In Vali’s case, I struggle with the proportionality of the punishment and Rama’s intervention. Can we justify any method simply because we believe the person being punished deserves it?

6.       Krishna, Arjuna, and Karna - Rules in an Unjust War

When Karna’s chariot wheel became stuck, he appealed to the conventions of combat. Krishna recalled Karna’s participation in earlier injustices such as the game of dice, standing by Duryodhana’s actions towards the Pandavas, and the slaughter of Abhimanyu (his own nephew). Accordingly, Arjuna shot his arrow and killed Karna. Traditional interpretations place this within the extraordinary moral and divine context of Kurukshetra especially after the ethics of battle were being broken on both sides.

Modern parallel: Imagine two competing companies. One steals confidential information or engages in unethical practices, setting off a chain of events, and the other retaliates by hacking its systems or spreading false information. Or consider a political campaign that justifies misinformation and character assassination of an opponent because its opponent has already resorted to similar tactics. Both sides eventually claim that their actions are necessary because the other side broke the rules first. Karna’s killing raises an uncomfortable question: if we abandon our principles whenever someone else violates them, what remains of those principles? Does another person’s wrongdoing automatically justify our own? If someone cheats you, do you cheat them back and hit below the belt as well? Do two wrongs make a right?

Final Thoughts – The Examples Don’t End Here

These episodes raise difficult questions about dharma, duty, loyalty, justice, and the exercise of power. What makes them particularly fascinating is that even characters we admire and revere can make decisions that leave us deeply uncomfortable.

But who are we to judge their actions thousands of years later, particularly when we continue to witness similar injustices in our own families, workplaces, and society?

And perhaps the more painful question is whether we ourselves would have acted any differently?

In Part 2, I’ll explore five more episodes from the Ramayana and Mahabharata, particularly those involving personal sacrifice, difficult choices, and the consequences borne by individuals who often had little say in the decisions that shaped their lives.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Was Destiny Already Preordained?

Ramayana – A Spectacular Retelling of Our Epic, With a Few Creative Liberties

Vibhishana and Kumbhakarna, Two Brothers Yet Two Very Different Paths